Battery damage in one night of low voltage?
softdown
Solar Expert Posts: 3,495 ✭✭✭✭
My case pertains to an auto battery. But the "science" carries over to off grid batteries.
Used the emergency flashers until they cut out and died. Was too late and tired to mess with a cold midnight. Charging this morning. Charger says battery started at "25 %" charged. Slightly less than 12 volts.
I do wonder if low voltage for a short period does significant damage. I would hope that the sulfation process would be more lengthy - at least a few days. A few weeks, or even months, would be much better.
Sometimes I use my solar batteries early in the morning prior to the sun naturally charging them. It is remarkable what a little internet and TV or computer can do to cold, morning voltage. Say 49.8 drops to 49.6ish for an hour or so. It does lengthen and intensify the recharge process. So should be avoided when possible. But how much real damage took place I wonder.
FWIW a cold (30Fish) 12.4 volts is a warm 12.5 volts. Or a cold 49.8 volts is a warm 50.2 volts.
TLDR: battery damage with 8 hours of low voltage?
Used the emergency flashers until they cut out and died. Was too late and tired to mess with a cold midnight. Charging this morning. Charger says battery started at "25 %" charged. Slightly less than 12 volts.
I do wonder if low voltage for a short period does significant damage. I would hope that the sulfation process would be more lengthy - at least a few days. A few weeks, or even months, would be much better.
Sometimes I use my solar batteries early in the morning prior to the sun naturally charging them. It is remarkable what a little internet and TV or computer can do to cold, morning voltage. Say 49.8 drops to 49.6ish for an hour or so. It does lengthen and intensify the recharge process. So should be avoided when possible. But how much real damage took place I wonder.
FWIW a cold (30Fish) 12.4 volts is a warm 12.5 volts. Or a cold 49.8 volts is a warm 50.2 volts.
TLDR: battery damage with 8 hours of low voltage?
First Bank:16 180 watt Grape Solar with FM80 controller and 3648 Inverter....Fullriver 8D AGM solar batteries. Second Bank/MacGyver Special: 10 165(?) watt BP Solar with Renogy MPPT 40A controller/ and Xantrex C-35 PWM controller/ and Morningstar PWM controller...Cotek 24V PSW inverter....forklift and diesel locomotive batteries
Comments
48 volts and below without a load are not good numbers for long life. You are not near that.
http://members.sti.net/offgridsolar/
E-mail [email protected]
How many times? Once - that I recall.
You are talking at an elementary level: "48 volts and below without a load are not good numbers for long life. You are not near that"
I was asking about "an hour of reduced voltage" for off grid batteries. Or 8 hours for an auto battery.
...your's might have frozen. You shouldn't try to charge frozen battery.
If you can live with the "unreliable battery" (have AAA available for jump start, carry some sort of Jump Start Battery, etc.), and don't want to spend the money time at this moment... You can try the old battery and see how things go.
If you need a reliable car and cannot get afford to get stranded/delayed--Get a new battery.
-Bill
The electronics seem to have shut down the battery drain at ~ 12 volts. I measured 12 volts when I started charging. "Charger says battery started at "25 %" charged. Slightly less than 12 volts." Edit: I measured 12.2 volts after ~ two minutes of charging. So 11.9 or 12 volts prior to charging is the estimate.
After charging I can put a decent battery tester on it and have a pretty good idea of its health. While asking advice on the internet often seems like a good idea - and often is - the responses have been a bit dramatic considering 12 volts for ~8 hours. Internet responses due tend to the dramatic.
I'm betting it will be fine and look forward to the test results.
My Explorer with the 2019 battery sat in a more declined state for a few months. It was obviously damaged but passes the tests as a decent battery. I'm sure it would be dead if made a few years earlier.
4 amp charger has brought it up to 12.9 volts so far. I suspect this charger will continue charging it for another 4-6 hours. Other chargers would have called it a day by now.
The Prius 12 volt is a fairly newish battery - I am told. Toyota chose to pretty well bury it in the back.
Tester: https://www.amazon.com/ANCEL-BA101-Professional-Automotive-Motorcycle/dp/B01M0ARG3X/ref=sr_1_6?keywords=ancel+battery+charger&qid=1582154409&sr=8-6
Got a feeling this whole episode is headed for comment deletion. It was pretty questionable to start with. Towing on black ice is exhausting. Exhausted takes awhile to recover from.
If the car's systems shut down at ~12.0 volts--Probably much less damage to the battery. It being cold, and charging the next morning--All good things.
Watch the battery charger... I had a cheap 1 amp trickle charger cube I put on a truly dead battery (10.5 volts or so). And after a few hours, it overheated and split the case wide open. Still works--But not a lot of confidence in that charger.
-Bill "moderator" B.
Healthy batteries take longer to charge and to discharge. The fact this it is charging for so long is heartening to me. Though 4 amps is not a powerful charge. Also - Prius batteries are ~33% smaller than typical V-8 batteries. Still costs a fairly similar amount. Maybe $20 less.
|| Midnight Classic 200 | 10, Evergreen 200w in a 160VOC array ||
|| VEC1093 12V Charger | Maha C401 aa/aaa Charger | SureSine | Sunsaver MPPT 15A
solar: http://tinyurl.com/LMR-Solar
gen: http://tinyurl.com/LMR-Lister ,
I would imagine the ~14' run from the fuse panel to the battery may slow down charging a significant amount. Tomorrow morning may be interesting indeed. I expect things to be fine at this time...
Big reason the forklift cells tend to be so robust. The plates are really, really thick on the big batteries.
Pretty soon I will find if the battery is OK or toast. Should have tested the voltage before charging. I wanted to see what the charger said - I like this Duracell 4 amp charger. It rated the charge at 25% - it only offers 25 and 50 and 75 and 100%. After ~ 2 minutes I disconnected it and read 12.2 volts.
EDit: Disconnected completed charge and read 13.19/13.2 volts at 8F. Or ~13.35 volts at 80F (temp compensated). Have not put the battery diagnostics on it but betting it is fine. One night at 12 volts ought not to be a huge deal at all.
And don't swallow any gas. Diarrhea is not much fun. Other than that - not too much to fume about.
if the battery is 4 years old it will Probably Die soon . Just my Experience
I'd have thought led flashers would be a smaller drain. Then again, Prius employs a small battery. I suspect that capacitors spend a second or two driving up the power level when starting. It always waits a second or two then boom - instant start. Doesn't crank at all. Just hesitates then starts. Prius are a bit odd. Recommend for city driving though - that is where Prius really shines.
I think people greatly exaggerated the harm in one night.
It is a new looking AC Delco AGM - likely made by Johnson Controls. Small - only offers 200 CCA. Looks like Prius calls for AGM batteries. Must be due to the proximity of fumes from the NiMH traction battery.
Turns out the Prius starter battery is very easy to access. Seen horrific exaggerations about "inaccessibility". People often don't have a clue how to rate difficulty.